Top
Unpaid Commission & Bonus Disputes

Long Island Unpaid Commission & Bonus Disputes

Unpaid Commissions & Bonuses: Your Rights to Recover Wages

Unpaid commission and bonus disputes examples reveal how employers illegally withhold, manipulate, or deny earned commissions and bonuses through contract violations, formula changes, or pretextual terminations. Below, we outline real-world examples of commission and bonus disputes, New York wage protections, evidence to preserve, and steps to recover what you're owed.

The Results are just the start

Verdicts that changed the law, and changed lives.
  • Class Action Over Withheld Tips Against Long Island Caterer

    Former servers, bussers, maître d’s, and other service staff filed a class action in Nassau County Supreme Court against a large Long Island catering company, alleging it unlawfully withheld as much as $10 million in tips and gratuities.

  • Nearly $3 Million Combined Settlement of Two Lawsuits Against Nassau County

    Two lawsuits against Nassau County were resolved through settlements approved by the county legislature.

  • $5 million verdict Federal Jury Verdict for Dean Fired After Complaining of Harassment

    A federal jury found that a Long Island middle school principal retaliated against the school’s dean of students after she complained of sexual harassment and racially and sexually charged comments, which led to her termination. She alleged that after she filed her complaint, the principal launched a campaign against her that included harassing her at work.

What Are Unpaid Commission and Bonus Disputes in Employment Law

Unpaid commission and bonus disputes arise when employers fail to pay earned commissions or bonuses as promised in employment contracts, commission plans, or bonus agreements. These disputes often involve contract interpretation, wage payment timing, and employer attempts to avoid paying earned compensation.

New York Labor Law treats commissions as wages that must be paid according to the terms of the agreement. When an employer enters into a commission agreement, those terms govern payment obligations and cannot be unilaterally changed to deprive employees of earned compensation.

Bonuses may be discretionary (employer decides whether and how much to pay) or non-discretionary (based on objective criteria, performance metrics, or contractual promises). Non-discretionary bonuses are considered earned wages that must be paid.

Common violations include terminating employees before commission payment dates to avoid paying earned commissions, retroactively changing commission formulas, denying bonuses through pretextual "discretion," stealing sales credits, imposing illegal clawback provisions, and failing to pay commissions on schedule.

  • Peer Reviewed - Dark
  • AVVO - Dark
  • Top NY Verdicts - Dark
  • Super Lawyers - Dark
  • Nassau County Bar Association - Dark

Overtime. Tips. Commissions. Shorted on Pay? Let’s Do the Math.
Unpaid overtime, withheld tips, missing bonuses, misclassification. We’ve recovered wages for New York workers for over 35 years, and your first consultation is free.
    A+ To this firm and Sean O’Hara!!
    “I highly recommend Sean!! He was ALWAYS responsive to any questions I had out of the blue, and extremely knowledgable and helpful!!”
    - Gabrielle M.
    Brett Cohen is the best!!! If you’re looking for a knowledgeable, ethical, and truly dedicated attorney, I highly recommend him.
    “If you’re looking for someone who genuinely cares and knows the law inside and out, he’s the one to call.”
    - Sharon M.
    Aaron Ferri never made me feel rushed, and you can tell he really cares about helping his clients and making sure they feel supported.
    “I’d definitely recommend him to anyone looking for an attorney who is reliable, easy to talk to, and truly great to work with. Thank you Aaron!”
    - Ariel B.
You're Worth Fighting For. We know the courts. We know the employers. We know your community.

this isn't just a case.
this is your life

  • By submitting, you agree to receive text messages from Leeds Brown Law at the number provided, including those related to your inquiry, follow-ups, and review requests, via automated technology. Consent is not a condition of purchase. Msg & data rates may apply. Msg frequency may vary. Reply STOP to cancel or HELP for assistance. Acceptable Use Policy
  • Results-Focused
    Every case aims at one thing: your economic recovery.
  • $350M+ Recovered
    Over 35 years of winning substantial results for our clients.
  • 35+ Years Strong
    Strong results, even when the odds look stacked against you.
  • Trusted Reputation
    Respected by clients, judges, and the legal community alike.
  • Client-First Care
    Attentive, compassionate counsel when your livelihood is on the line.