Common FMLA & NYPFL Violations We Fight
Employers can violate these laws in many ways, from outright denial to more subtle forms of interference and punishment. As a leading **FMLA lawyer in NYC**, our firm frequently litigates cases involving these common violations:
Wrongful Denial of Leave
You may have a claim if your employer incorrectly tells you that you are not eligible for leave, denies a valid request without a legitimate reason, or delays the approval process unreasonably. If you were **denied medical leave in NY** for a qualifying serious health condition for yourself or a family member, your employer may be in direct violation of the law.
Retaliation for Requesting or Taking Leave
This is one of the most serious and common violations. **Retaliation for taking FMLA** or NYPFL is strictly illegal. It can take many forms, including:
- Terminating your employment shortly after you request leave or return from it.
- Demoting you or moving you to a less desirable position upon your return.
- Reducing your pay, hours, or responsibilities.
- Giving you an unfair negative performance review.
- Subjecting you to harassment or a hostile work environment for taking leave.
Employers will often try to disguise retaliation by creating a false reason (a “pretext”) for the negative action. Our attorneys are skilled at uncovering this pretext and proving the employer’s true, illegal motive.
Interference with Your Rights
An employer cannot interfere with, restrain, or deny your attempt to exercise your FMLA or NYPFL rights. Interference can include:
- Discouraging you from taking leave.
- Failing to inform you of your rights and responsibilities under the law.
- Using your taking of leave as a negative factor in employment actions, such as hiring, promotions, or disciplinary decisions.
- Requiring you to perform work while you are on protected leave.
Failure to Reinstate to an Equivalent Position
A cornerstone of these laws is **job protection under FMLA and NYPFL**. When you return from leave, you must be reinstated to your original job or an “equivalent” position. An equivalent position must be virtually identical in terms of pay, benefits, shift, location, and other terms and conditions of employment. An employer cannot bring you back to a dead-end role with fewer responsibilities as a form of punishment.
Protecting New Parents: Your Right to Bonding Leave
Both FMLA and NYPFL provide job-protected leave for parents to bond with a newborn, newly adopted, or newly placed foster child. New York Paid Family Leave is particularly beneficial, providing partial wage replacement during this critical time. If your employer has denied your request for time off after the birth or adoption of your child, you should immediately contact a **bonding leave lawyer in NYC** to protect your rights and your growing family.
What to Do If Your Leave Rights Have Been Violated
If you believe your employer has violated your FMLA or NYPFL rights, it is crucial to act strategically to protect your claim.
- Keep All Documentation: Save copies of all leave request forms, emails to and from HR or your manager, doctor’s notes, and any denial letters.
- Document Everything: Keep a private log of all conversations related to your leave. Note the dates, who you spoke with, and what was said.
- Preserve Performance Records: Gather copies of your past performance reviews, emails praising your work, and any other documents that show you were a competent employee. This can help defeat an employer’s claim that you were fired for “poor performance.”
- Contact an Experienced Employment Lawyer: Navigating the complexities of federal and state leave laws can be difficult. An attorney can evaluate your case, explain your options, and handle all communications with your employer.
Contact a New York FMLA and Paid Family Leave Attorney
You should never have to choose between your job and your family’s health or your own well-being. The law protects your right to do both. If your employer has denied you leave or punished you for taking it, the attorneys at Leeds Brown Law are here to fight for you.
We have decades of experience representing employees in complex FMLA and NYPFL cases across Nassau County, Suffolk County, and the five boroughs of New York City. We understand the tactics employers use and how to build a powerful case to secure the compensation and justice you deserve. Contact us today for a free and confidential consultation.
Call us at (516) 276-9946 or fill out our online form to get started.
FMLA Violations Examples: What Illegal Leave Denials Look Like
FMLA violations examples reveal how employers illegally deny, interfere with, or retaliate against employees who request family and medical leave. Below, we outline real-world examples of FMLA violations, your federal leave protections, evidence to preserve, and steps to protect your rights.
What Are FMLA Violations in Employment Law
FMLA violations occur when employers illegally deny, interfere with, or retaliate against employees exercising rights under the Family and Medical Leave Act. The FMLA provides eligible employees up to 12 weeks of unpaid, job-protected leave per year.
The Family and Medical Leave Act covers serious health conditions affecting you or your immediate family, childbirth and bonding with a new child, and certain military family situations. Employers with 50 or more employees must comply.
To be eligible, you must have worked for the employer for at least 12 months, worked at least 1,250 hours in the past year, and work at a location with 50+ employees within 75 miles.
Common violations include denying FMLA requests, terminating employees on leave, refusing to reinstate workers after leave, counting FMLA leave against attendance policies, and creating obstacles that discourage employees from taking leave they're entitled to use.
12 Powerful FMLA Violations Examples (Real-World Patterns)
1) Denying FMLA Leave Despite Meeting Eligibility Requirements
You meet all eligibility criteria and have a qualifying medical condition, but your employer denies your FMLA request claiming you're "not eligible," the timing is "inconvenient," or the company is "too busy."
Denying leave to eligible employees for non-medical reasons is a clear FMLA violation example and subjects employers to significant liability.
2) Termination or Discipline While on Protected Leave
While you're on approved FMLA leave, your employer terminates you, eliminates your position, or claims you abandoned your job. The Department of Labor prohibits adverse actions during FMLA leave.
3) Refusing Reinstatement After Leave Ends
You return from FMLA leave with medical clearance, but the employer claims your position no longer exists, has been filled, or you're no longer needed. FMLA guarantees reinstatement to the same or equivalent position.
4) Counting FMLA Leave Against Attendance or Performance
Your employer includes FMLA absences in attendance point systems, cites leave in performance reviews, or uses protected leave as a basis for discipline. FMLA leave cannot be counted as negative attendance.
5) Retaliation After Requesting or Taking FMLA Leave
After requesting leave, you experience demotion, reduced hours, worse assignments, increased scrutiny, or a hostile work environment. Retaliation for exercising FMLA rights violates federal law.
Timing between leave requests and adverse actions is critical evidence of retaliation.
6) Requiring More Medical Documentation Than Allowed
Your employer demands excessive medical details, requires recertification more frequently than regulations allow, or contacts your healthcare provider directly without authorization. FMLA limits employer requests for medical information.
7) Discouraging or Intimidating Employees From Taking Leave
Management makes comments like "we really need you here," suggests taking leave will hurt your career, or creates a culture where leave requests are met with hostility. Interference with FMLA rights includes discouragement.
8) Failing to Designate Leave as FMLA-Protected
You notify your employer of a qualifying condition, but they don't inform you that your leave qualifies as FMLA. Later, they claim you took unauthorized time off. Employers must designate qualifying leave as FMLA.
9) Denying Intermittent or Reduced Schedule Leave
Your doctor certifies you need intermittent FMLA leave for ongoing treatment or flare-ups, but your employer insists you take continuous leave blocks or denies the intermittent arrangement. FMLA allows intermittent leave when medically necessary.
10) Requiring Use of Paid Leave Before FMLA Approval
Management forces you to exhaust all paid vacation or sick time before they'll consider your FMLA request. While employers can require concurrent use of paid leave, they cannot delay FMLA protection.
11) Transferring to Less Desirable Position Upon Return
You return from FMLA leave and are assigned to a different shift, location, or role with reduced responsibilities or pay. FMLA requires equivalent position restoration - not just any position.
An equivalent position means comparable duties, pay, benefits, and working conditions.
12) Refusing to Provide FMLA Information or Forms
You request FMLA leave, but HR refuses to provide required notices, claim forms, or information about your rights. Employers must post FMLA notices and provide eligibility information when leave is requested.
Evidence That Proves FMLA Violations
- FMLA Requests: Written leave requests, medical certifications, and employer responses or denials.
- Medical Documentation: Doctor's notes, certifications, and treatment records supporting your need for leave.
- Timeline: Dates of leave requests, approval/denial, and any adverse actions like termination or demotion.
- Communications: Emails, texts, or notes showing discouragement, intimidation, or retaliation related to leave.
- Company Policies: Employee handbooks, FMLA policies, or attendance policies that show violations.
- Comparative Evidence: How other employees' leave requests were handled versus yours.
Submit all FMLA requests in writing via email or certified mail. Keep copies of all medical certifications submitted.
Document any comments about your leave request or treatment changes after requesting leave. Save all communications regarding reinstatement.
What You Can Recover in FMLA Violations Cases
- Reinstatement to your position or equivalent role
- Back pay for lost wages and benefits during unlawful denial
- Front pay if reinstatement isn't feasible
- Liquidated damages equal to back pay for willful violations
- Compensation for out-of-pocket medical expenses
- Restoration of benefits lost due to violation
- Attorneys' fees and court costs
Next Steps if You Recognize These FMLA Violations Examples
- Document your leave request: Submit FMLA requests in writing and keep copies of all submissions.
- Obtain medical certification: Get proper documentation from your healthcare provider supporting leave.
- Track timeline: Note dates of request, approval/denial, leave taken, and any adverse actions.
- Preserve communications: Save all emails, texts, and notes about your leave or return to work.
- Know your eligibility: Verify you meet the 12 months, 1,250 hours, and location requirements.
- Consult an attorney promptly: FMLA claims must be filed within 2-3 years; quick action is essential.
To schedule a consultation, call (516) 276-9946 or reach us via the contact form below. Early legal action protects your leave rights and employment.