Employee Misclassification Examples in NY
Employee Misclassification: Signs of Illegal Contractor Status
Employee misclassification examples help workers recognize when they're wrongly labeled as independent contractors to deny them wages, benefits, and legal protections. Below, we outline real-world examples of employee misclassification, the tests courts use to determine employment status, evidence to collect, and steps to recover what you're owed.
The Results are just the start
Verdicts that changed the law, and changed lives.
-
$5 million verdict Federal Jury Verdict for Dean Fired After Complaining of Harassment
A federal jury found that a Long Island middle school principal retaliated against the school’s dean of students after she complained of sexual harassment and racially and sexually charged comments, which led to her termination. She alleged that after she filed her complaint, the principal launched a campaign against her that included harassing her at work.
-
Nearly $3 Million Combined Settlement of Two Lawsuits Against Nassau County
Two lawsuits against Nassau County were resolved through settlements approved by the county legislature.
-
Class Action Over Withheld Tips Against Long Island Caterer
Former servers, bussers, maître d’s, and other service staff filed a class action in Nassau County Supreme Court against a large Long Island catering company, alleging it unlawfully withheld as much as $10 million in tips and gratuities.
What Is Employee Misclassification in Employment Law
Employee misclassification occurs when an employer incorrectly labels a worker as an independent contractor (1099) instead of an employee (W-2) to avoid paying minimum wage, overtime, payroll taxes, unemployment insurance, workers' compensation, and employee benefits. Federal law (Fair Labor Standards Act), IRS regulations, and New York State Labor Law use multi-factor tests to determine true employment status based on the economic reality of the relationship—not just what the contract says. Key factors include who controls how, when, and where work is performed; whether the worker can profit or lose based on managerial skill; the permanence of the relationship; whether the work is integral to the employer's business; and the worker's investment in equipment and facilities. Misclassification is illegal and deprives workers of minimum wage, overtime pay, paid sick leave, unemployment benefits, workers' compensation coverage, and anti-discrimination protections. Common violations occur in construction, delivery services, home care, tech platforms, trucking, and salon industries.
-
“If you’re looking for attorneys who truly care about their clients and deliver real results, I highly recommend Leeds Brown. I’m incredibly grateful for everything they did for me. I highly recommend you give them a call. They are the best!!”- Kristin E.
-
“I would absolutely work with Aaron and the Leeds Brown team again and highly recommend them to anyone looking for outstanding legal representation.”- Iman F.
-
“We planned out a strategy to move forward and I am highly confident in his and the law firms ability in handling my case.”- Dominick M.